Plans for combined devolution deal for Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire look like a dog's dinner, says Newark MP Robert Jenrick

Robert Jenrick told the Advertiser: “I have considerable reservations about adding yet another layer of local government, costing hard-pressed taxpayers millions of pounds for more politicians and more bureaucracy.

“Residents of Newark would have a town council, a district council, a county council, a combined authority, a police and crime commissioner and an elected mayor.

“Nobody would know who was responsible for what, other than seeing their council tax bill increase for the pleasure of it all.”

Mr Jenrick added it was clear public spending would be under great pressure in the years ahead, and that people rightly wanted lower taxes.

He said: “For a range of historic reasons our area already has amongst the highest council taxes in the country.

“I support the creation of elected mayors, and created more as Secretary of State, where there either already is streamlined local government or where a reduction in tiers of government is part of the deal.

“That’s how I did it when I created mayors in South and West Yorkshire and set in train mayors in Cumbria and North Yorkshire.

“The proposal for a Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire looks increasingly like a dog’s dinner and the taxpayer will be left to pay the bill.”

Nottinghamshire County Council said key areas for greater autonomy and funding highlighted in the submission included transport and infrastructure, business growth, inward investment, strategic regeneration, destination management, employment, education, and skills. Council resources could also be pooled to make them go further.

The combined authority submission follows the publication of the government’s Levelling Up White Paper, in which local leaders were asked to put forward a vision for devolved powers and improved services in their area.

The four council leaders recently had a meeting with minister Neil O’Brien MP who said the government was encouraged by the level of ambition of the authorities, and that he expected a good deal for the region could be agreed.

The combined authority would be home to around 2.2m residents, which would make it the third biggest of its kind in the country. All the councils involved, including district and borough councils in these areas, would retain all their powers.

The county council said the deal would not create a new tier of government but would bring a level of government which already exists from Westminster to the East Midlands.

Ben Bradley MP, leader of Nottinghamshire County Council, said his priority was to improve the lives of local people and that going for a lesser deal wouldn’t allow this.

He said: “We owe it to our residents, and to future generations, to be ambitious and to get the best possible deal for the county and the East Midlands, working to bring in new investment, more and better jobs, better public transport, an improved environment, and more opportunities for skills and training. That means that a high-level combined authority deal should be our focus.

“If we go for a lesser option that won’t bring about the big improvements that we want to see. We want to stand alongside other areas like the West Midlands and Greater Manchester, in terms of getting our fair share of investment, having a bigger voice, and getting the means to deliver positive change for our communities.

“We all know there has been underinvestment in our area when compared to London and the south-east, and this is our chance to address that. Local council leaders already work well together on large scale projects including public health, economic development, environmental strategy, and many other areas, so this would build on existing collaboration.

“We still have a way to go and there is a lot to be confirmed, but this is a very positive step. Our areas have a lot in common, and I believe a joint deal makes a lot of sense.

“We’re working really well as partners on this. I’m optimistic. I think the prospects for getting a really great deal for the East Midlands are high.”

“I’m determined to make the most of this opportunity so we can see better outcomes for our residents.”

Nottingham City Council leader David Mellen said: “The East Midlands has been underfunded for many years compared to other parts of the country and so it makes sense for us to look very seriously at anything that could help to redress the balance.

“This isn’t just about what the government wants from us, it’s also about what the government can offer us — investment in jobs and regeneration and additional powers that can help us meet our full potential.

“A combined authority involving Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, Derby and Derbyshire councils would build on our existing strengths and shared vision to benefit over two million residents across our counties and cities.

“We need government to back these plans and give us the best deal to benefit our region. There also needs to be further consultation and engagement with citizens before any deal is reached.”

Barry Lewis, leader of Derbyshire County Council, said: “This is potentially a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to redress underfunding by successive governments and to ultimately improve life for local people through new investment, better training and job opportunities, and upgraded and more connected public transport.

“Our residents deserve nothing less than for us to seize this opportunity on their behalf and to put forward a strong and ambitious case to government — a case that has the greatest potential to deliver the biggest improvements for our communities.

“This is what we have done with today’s submission of proposals for a county deal devolution agreement, which if successful could be delivered through a combined authority for Derbyshire, Derby, Nottinghamshire and Nottingham.

“Our case to government builds on our many combined strengths as a region — our existing partnerships and collaboration, our place at the heart of the country, our world class universities, our commitment to green innovation, clean energy growth and improving and protecting our natural environment in both urban and rural areas.

“A devolution deal would simply enable us to deliver more for local people and that’s what is at the heart of it all. Our submission to government transcends administrative and political boundaries to deliver the very best levelling up opportunities for Derbyshire.”

Chris Poulter, leader of Derby City Council, said: “The government’s Levelling Up White Paper offers Derby and our wider region real opportunities for much needed investment. This is a significant opportunity for us to better represent our people and businesses through local level decision-making, with devolved powers and funding.

“The meeting was a very positive step in our conversations with government, which should act as a catalyst for securing our region’s fair share of national funding and support.

“The East Midlands has long been overlooked, in comparison to other combined authority areas like the West Midlands and Greater Manchester — public spending per person is lowest in the East Midlands at £12,113 — 10% below the UK average.

“We’ve demonstrated our commitment to working together, and I’m reassured by the constructive conversations between all councils.

“As individual authorities we exist to serve and support our residents. We’re convinced that by leaning on our collective resources we can only improve the efficiency and value for money of services provided for our people.”